I need to explain the motivation behind this list. See, typically, I would avoid a list like this. The subject is just too broad and, while I like a little film discussion, I hate hearing about 900 people I left off my lists from you commenters (who I love). It just chips away slowly at my huge, Superman-like ego. However, I was inspired and here’s why…
Last week, I attended my first NFL game and had the joy of watching the Green Bay Packers defeat the San Diego Chargers (Go Pack Go!). As a result, I also enjoyed my first tailgating experience, which was amazing. The strange thing about it though is that the police are constantly driving by and monitoring the parking lot. It’s the only time in my life, I’ve been hammered drunk in public, with an open container in my hand, five feet from a police cruiser and not hassled. In fact, most times I was greeted by a kind wave or knowing nod. It was amazing. So, I’ve decided to honor the Men in Blue (Not Black… they fight aliens) with this list of my favorite movie cops. Let’s do this:
HONORABLE MENTION: T-1000 (TERMINATOR 2: JUDGEMENT DAY).
While he’d typically be a Top 3 pick, I just couldn’t bring myself to count him. After all, he’s not really a cop. He just plays one when he time travels.
10. HARTIGAN (SIN CITY).
Sin City is a severely underrated movie. Most people like it but I believe it should be lauded. The unfortunate thing is that the performances are often overshadowed by the technical creativity of the film. It’s unfortunate because Willis actually turns in a great performance as a Hartigan. A walking, talking stereotype that encapsulates everything a pulpy, beat detective should be.
9. STANSFIELD (LEON: THE PROFESSIONAL).
No offense to Commissioner Gordon (who just missed the list) but Stansfield is definitely Oldman’s best turn as a cop. How do you not love a crooked cop who commits more crimes than the people he puts behind bars while always maintaining a drug induced haze?
8. WALKER (TIMECOP).
Timecop is a great film. Even with JCVD in the lead role cheesing everything up with his mullet. I’m really surprised this film didn’t fall to a bigger star or that it hasn’t been remade for one. Still, it’s a damn fun film and you can’t help but root for Walker as he races through time to save his wife, Van Damnit!
7. JIM MALONE (THE UNTOUCHABLES).
Connery is a bad-ass. No one is debating that. Even when he does something ridiculous… like play an Irish cop with a Scottish accent. In The Untouchables, you can’t help but love him as the real brains behind the crew that brought down Capone and for bringing the guns to a gun fight.
6. AXEL FOLEY (BEVERLY HILLS COP).
I wish I could phonetically write Eddie Murphy’s laugh because that is half of the genius behind the success of these films. Now, most people would probably have him higher on their lists. I love the guy but not that much. Still, you have to respect this character when making a list like this one. After all, it made Murphy a star. On a funny side-note, did you know Stallone turned down this role for not being serious enough and made Cobra instead. Good call, Sly!
5. DET. ALONZO HARRIS (TRAINING DAY).
Our second crooked cop on the list is just awesome. I know this because, little known fact, I’m not a huge Denzel fan. I think he’s a great actor but he bugs me in a lot of his roles. However, in this film, I thought it was great to see him play the role of the villain and, unlike many other people, I think it was great to see him take home Oscar gold for it.
4. JOHNNY UTAH (POINT BREAK).
Okay, technically he’s an F-B-I Agent! But a cop’s a cop and I’ll allow it. And since it’s my post, I CAN DO WHATEVER THE HELL I WANT! (tee-hee) A lot of people like to bag on Reeves’ performances but there are some roles he was born to play. Utah is one of them. Not only is he balls to the wall in his pursuit of Boadie but he also never lets his friendship with the criminal get in the way of the job.
3. CAREY MAHONEY (POLICE ACADEMY 2: THE FIRST ASSIGNMENT).
What is this guy doing in such great company, you might ask? Look, everybody loves Police Academy. If you don’t, you should probably just bang your testicles with a mallet! And “The Gutts” (as I like to call him) as Mahoney makes these movies great. Need proof? How great were those sequels they did without him? Point. Win.
2. MARTIN RIGGS (LETHAL WEAPON).
Do you remember when everybody loved Mel Gibson? Me neither but that time apparently did exist. Look, Riggs is probably the funnest to watch on the list but I can’t give him the #1 spot. However, I’ve got to give the man props for, if nothing else, that magic trick he can do with his shoulder.
1. JOHN McCLANE (DIE HARD).
I realize it’s a boring #1 pick but so what? He earned it, damnit. Besides he gave me a shot-out in the film. Did you miss it? It’s the part where he said Yippee-Kai-Ay, Mr. Falcon!
So, who are some of your favorite movie cops?
















Twitter: joelburman
November 14, 2011 4:16 am
Maniac Cop!!!!
Twitter: waywardjam
November 14, 2011 1:36 pm
Maniac Cop never gets the love.
Nicholas Angel, Hot Fuzz??
Otherwise great list. Oh and Jackie Chan in Rush Hour is pretty epic too.
Twitter: kaiderman
November 14, 2011 6:56 pm
No but good call. And I actually considered Chris Tucker fron Rush Hour and Jackie Chan from Supercop.
No love for The busty cops?
Twitter: kaiderman
November 14, 2011 6:56 pm
Uhwhaaaaaah?
Nice list Kai. But I’m surprised not to see Dirty Harry in there
Twitter: kaiderman
November 14, 2011 6:58 pm
Not a Harry fan. In old school Eastwood, I prefer his Westerns.
Here is the real ten movie cops list.
10 Rick Deckard 9 Bill Gillespie 8 Bud Exley 7 Jim Malone 6 Marge Gunderson 5 John McClane 4 Frank Serpico 3 Harry Callahan 2 Popeye Doyle 1 Frank Bullitt.
Hon Ment: Mr Orange, Axel Foley, Inspector Clouseau, John Book, Nicholas Angel, Frank Derbin
Twitter: kaiderman
November 14, 2011 6:59 pm
Great list, Strange order. All of those were considered, for the most part. Exley was #11.
Twitter: twscritic
November 14, 2011 1:39 pm
Nice list, but I think the awesomeness of Samurai Cop should have been included.
Twitter: waywardjam
November 14, 2011 1:41 pm
Harry Callahan is a must have for my list.
I’m just happy Willis took 2 spots in your list. He’s practically an honorary cop considering how many he’s played over the years.
Twitter: kaiderman
November 14, 2011 7:03 pm
Agreed!
No Serpico?
And technically, Johnny Utah was FBI.
If you’re allowing FBI, I have to complain about the lack of Clarice Starling, too.
Twitter: kaiderman
November 14, 2011 7:01 pm
I hate Clarice. Mentioned the FBI thing in the post.
Serpico was my #12.
I realized I didn’t write that up well when I left it. I saw that you wrote that in your post, I should have phrased it “Since you’re allowing Johnny Utah,” but… no comment edits, you know how it goes.
But… wait. What? You hate Clarice Starling?
Twitter: kaiderman
November 15, 2011 6:07 pm
Sorry if I was short in responding. I got accidentally drunk last night and was having problems typing. In response, I may be the only person in the world who doesn’t covet Silence of the Lambs. Not a huge fan aside from Hopkins performance. I realize I am in the minority on this one.
Well, we all have views in the minority at some point in time…
I’m sure getting drunk was “accidental”.
Twitter: heather_kenobi
November 15, 2011 10:26 am
Is it because she seems frigid? She seems frigid to me……also her eyes water so much…frigid and watery is not a good combination for law enforcement.
Twitter: kaiderman
November 15, 2011 6:08 pm
You’re frigid!
Twitter: kaiderman
November 15, 2011 6:08 pm
Yeah… I said it!
Twitter: heather_kenobi
November 16, 2011 5:55 am
I’m a lot of things…….I’m not sure frigid is one of them….hehehehe
Twitter: waywardjam
November 15, 2011 1:22 pm
Which Clarice Starling do you hate? I assume Jodie and not Julianne.
Twitter: kaiderman
November 15, 2011 6:08 pm
haha…
Twitter: ScribeHard
November 14, 2011 4:03 pm
LOVE Die Hard‘s McClane in the one-spot, but Dirty Harry‘s Harry Callahan is a glaring hole in the list. And what, no love for Robocop?
Twitter: kaiderman
November 14, 2011 7:01 pm
Fair point but, no, no Robocop. Top 20 for me.
Twitter: fandangogroover
November 15, 2011 8:06 am
John McClane is a good number one. If you watch the movie on pre-watershed British TV he says “Yippee-Kai-Ay, Mellon Farmer”.
A few that may have made my list:
Max Rockatansky
Harry Callahan
Bud White
Vincent Hanna
Captain Renault
Twitter: kaiderman
November 15, 2011 6:10 pm
Oops, I said earlier Exle was my number 11 but I meant Bud.
On TV here, he says Mr. Falcon. It’s HI-larious!!!
Twitter: heather_kenobi
November 15, 2011 10:24 am
I would have liked to have seen Axel lower, and of course my Bad Boys who are in charge of shit getting real, but overall I like the variety you have here, and Yippy Kai Yay! as number one is totally bad ass. One cop you definitely missed though was Bud White because I fucking love LA Confidential, but that’s a personal obsession……….good work
Twitter: kaiderman
November 15, 2011 6:12 pm
Yeah, I had him #11. The more I think about it, the more I realize how great he was. I probably should shimmy him in here.
Twitter: heather_kenobi
November 16, 2011 5:56 am
I vote for a shimmy.
Twitter: ptsnob
November 15, 2011 9:44 pm
Good list. A lot of the ones that I first thought of were on there. Love seeing the Timecop appearance. Nice move with that one.
Another good Al Pacino pick (along with Serpico) is Vincent Hanna in Heat. I’ll also support the Bud White pick in L.A. Confidential, and Ed Exley isn’t a bad choice either from that movie.
Twitter: Top10Films
December 14, 2011 3:44 am
The Police Academy films wouldn’t work in my opinion without Steve Guttenberg. Although the films get worse generally there’s a great hole left when he’s not in them. Which is shame for an actor with some talent – I think the only films I remember him from with any fondness are the Police Academy and Three Men and a Baby films.
…Cocoon was okay..of course there’s Diner but hardly his best performance. The Hitchcockian The Bedroom Window was good.
…my faves include McClane and Axel Foley of course!